Skip to main content

Refine for journals

Free for journals in our partner programme

Catch the errors referees don't have time to find.

A technical report on each manuscript: gaps in proofs, tables that contradict the text, claims the analysis doesn't support. Your journal contracts it, it stays confidential, and your editors decide.

Used in the publication processes of

American Economic Association
The Econometric Society

What your editors get

A technical report, finding by finding.

Specific enough to act on, short enough to read before the decision letter.

  • Tied to the exact passageEvery finding quotes the text it's about and opens it in the manuscript.
  • Ranked by severityCritical and major first. Editors can hide the minor ones.
  • Technical findings only, if you preferSwitch the overall assessment on or off for your journal.
  • Checks the revisionOn resubmission, Refine checks whether each earlier comment was addressed.

Where it fits

Use it at the stage you choose.

Your editors decide which manuscripts get a report, and when.

Before referees

Send out a checked paper

Referees start from the technical issues already found, and spend their time on judgment.

Revise and resubmit

See what the revision fixed

Check the new version against the last round, comment by comment.

Before acceptance

A last technical pass

Catch what slipped through before the paper goes to production.

What Refine checks

  • Proofs and derivations
  • Internal consistency
  • Tables and figures against the text
  • Claims against the evidence
  • Notation
  • References, checked against the source
  • Plagiarism detectionComing soon
  • Code and replication packagesComing soon

Keep your image and paper-mill checks: Refine works alongside them.

Confidentiality and AI policy

Built for the rules your publisher already has.

Most publishers don't let referees upload manuscripts to AI tools on their own. They allow tools the journal contracts, when confidentiality is assured.

What mattersA referee's own AI toolRefine, contracted by your journal
Who decides it's usedThe referee, often against journal policyYour editors
Training on manuscriptsDepends on the tool's termsNever, by contract with every model provider
Retention at model providersDepends on the tool's termsZero data retention
Who owns the manuscriptUnclearYour journal
Who sees the reportThe refereeOnly the people your editors choose
Decisions—Advisory only: no accept or reject recommendation
  • SOC 2 Type 2
  • ISO 27001
  • GDPR
  • No training on manuscripts

For the editorial office

One account for your editorial team.

  • Invite your editors

    The managing editor adds co-editors by email.

  • Private to each editor

    Each editor sees only their own manuscripts. We set this up for your journal.

  • Editors change; the account stays

    Remove someone when their term ends. Nothing is lost.

  • Share a report

    Send the review to an author or referee as a link.

Independent checks

Tested by the people who would know.

9 in 10

reviews won head-to-head against frontier AI reviewers, on 150 economics preprints

97.8%

of comments pointed to a real issue, in mathematician Daniel Litt's audit of 20 of his own papers

1,300+

universities where your authors may already check their papers with Refine

Benchmark and audit details on Why Refine. Universities counted by researchers' email domains.

Free pilot

Free for journals.

1

Tell us about your journal

Volumes, stages and who should see reports.

2

Start right away

Your editors are set up immediately. No integration needed.

3

Run it on real manuscripts

Agree what success looks like, then decide.

We take on a limited number of journals at a time.

Are you a referee?

Ask your journal to bring Refine in.

Most journals don't allow referees to upload manuscripts to AI tools on their own. Tell us which journal you review for, and we'll talk to its editors.

Suggest your journal

FAQ

Questions editors ask us

Bring Refine to your journal.

Tell us about your journal and we'll shape a free pilot with your editors.

If you're a referee, tell us which journal you review for.

Or email us directly at institutional-support@refine.ink.